Home > Uncategorized > Why is populism on the rise and what do populists want?

Why is populism on the rise and what do populists want?

from Dean Baker

In the United States, the pay of a typical worker has badly trailed productivity growth over the last four decades, allowing only marginal improvements in living standards over this period. At the same time, a small number of people have gotten incredibly rich in the finance and tech sectors and by being top executives in major U.S. corporations. There is a similar, if somewhat less stark, picture in most other wealthy countries.

The standard story for this rise in inequality is that this is just the inevitable course of globalization and technology. While many in the elite may feel bad for those left behind, and even propose policies to help them, the line is that the rise in inequality is something that happened, not the result of conscious policy.

That is a lie. And the persistence of this lie is one of the reasons that populist politics has so much resonance in Europe and the United States. 

There was nothing inevitable about who would be winners from technology and globalization. Those who won have been successful because they wrote the rules and run the institutions. It is that simple.

Starting with technology, the fact that people like Bill Gates can get incredibly rich is not only due to the fact that they may be smart and hardworking. People like Bill Gates can get incredibly rich because we have patent and copyright laws that give them monopolies over items like Windows. Without these government-granted monopolies, there would be far less money in software, pharmaceuticals, medical equipment, and many other important sectors of the economy.

Patent and copyright monopolies are explicitly policy levers to provide incentives for innovation and creative work. We can make them shorter and weaker if we choose, as opposed to longer and stronger, which has been the pattern over the last four decades. Pretending that the money going to the winners from these monopolies is natural is an absurdity that deserves nothing but ridicule. Instead, this is the accepted wisdom in intellectual circles.

The comparable wisdom about globalization is that manufacturing workers in rich countries lose because hundreds of millions of people can do the same work in the developing world for a fraction of the pay.

This is true, but it is also true that there are tens of millions smart and hardworking people in the developing world who would be prepared to work as doctors, dentists, and in other highly paid professions in the rich countries at a fraction of the pay of the people now in those positions. We structured our trade policy so manufacturing workers have to compete with workers in the developing world and doctors and dentists mostly do not.

We have structured our financial system to allow a small number of people to get tremendously rich at the expense of the economy as a whole. This was demonstrated most clearly in the wake of the collapse of the housing bubble when political elites raced to save the big banks from the consequences of their own actions, but there are many ways in which the rules have been structured to support a bloated financial sector.

And we have had macroeconomic policy that has needlessly kept millions of people from having jobs. It has also reduced the bargaining power of tens of millions who do have jobs. It is not surprising that policies designed to redistribute income upward would lead to resentment, especially when our elites pretend they do not exist. Until these policies are acknowledged and changed, populist anger is not likely to go away.

  1. April 5, 2019 at 3:25 am

    Gleaned from Gail Tverberg and others it appears that our productive civilization peaked at around the time of the Moon shots. Then came the oil shocks and by the end of the 1970’s we were well into the start of the credit boom. The credit boom does not rely on labour so much as it is the wealthy who control credit that gain the most advantage. Consequently labour stagnated while the FIRE sector cornered more and more of the gains. Productivity hasn’t stopped of course, what with a population boom to address, but it’s not the driver it once was. It’s mostly maintenance and incremental improvements we see today alongside new communications and computing industries. So labour is more administrative than productive.
    Remuneration has not kept pace and for poorer workers gains have been miserable, This is creating the conditions for civil unrest, of which Brexit is a warning sign. A change of direction is imperative.

  2. Helge Nome
    April 5, 2019 at 5:09 am

    There is a hidden nuclear bomb here:
    Our youth is to a large extent excluded from meaningful participation in the productive system. So they languish in frustration and anger. That means that they can easily be weaponized by turning anger into action against the society that produced them. The emergence of ISIS is just a symptom of a deep malaise.

    And all because of the greed and craving for grandeur of a small number of psychopaths.

  3. John Hermann
    April 5, 2019 at 6:01 am

    I agree with you Helge, however one should also ask what caused those psychopaths to develop within our society. It is my contention that the cause of this dysfunction is the same as that which has produced disadvantaged, poorly remunerated and restless young people (on whom the pyschopaths prey), namely neoliberalism and the neoliberal agenda. One of the most destructive aspects of neoliberalism is its tendency to transform normal human beings into con artists, fraudsters, narcissists, sociopaths and psychopaths.

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.