Home > Uncategorized > “It’s a lose-lose” for workers

“It’s a lose-lose” for workers

from David Ruccio

It’s now an almost daily occurrence: Donald Trump starring in the White House pandemic briefings, flanked by business executives—from Walgreens, CVS, Target and a host of laboratory, research, and medical-device corporations—to form a mutual admiration society.* The various scientists, public-health experts, and emergency personnel, the ones people want to hear from, are accorded third rank.

And American workers are nowhere to be seen—or heard—even when, as on 24 March, Trump decided to speak for them as wanting nothing more than “to get back to work.”

The fact is, while millions and millions of workers have been furloughed or laid off in recent weeks, waiting desperately to receive financial assistance, many more continue to be forced to have the freedom to labor for their employers on a daily basis. They leave their families and venture out—too many with no alternative but to expose themselves to the risks of the pandemic during their commute on public transportation—and then submit to even more risks on their jobs, with little in the way of protection, as some of their fellow workers contract COVID-19.


As Francis Prose explained, many working-class people don’t have the luxury of social distancing on their way to work:

Among the most disturbing are the photos and videos of jam-packed New York subway stations and cars, crowded with passengers – mostly people of color – on their way to work. Some passengers are wearing masks, some aren’t. Whether they like their jobs, believe in what they do, worry about health protections at work, fear losing their health insurance, if they have any, they probably have something in common: they wouldn’t be on this packed subway if they didn’t have to be.

And then, once they get to work, there are the dangers of laboring alongside others or interacting with possibly infected clients and customers. Think of all the hospital workers and other first responders, supermarket clerks, janitors, and nursing-home aids, as well as all the other members of the working-class who cannot work from home, but have no choice but to go their jobs in the factories, stores, and delivery services run by the CEOs who are fêted at Trump’s briefings.

It’s no wonder, then, that Amazon driver Maurice Baze called the situation “a lose-lose.”

If I don’t go to work, I can’t pay my rent. If I do go, I could get sick and never work again because I lost my life.

American workers, lest we forget, live in a country with no federal laws requiring paid leave for family matters or their own health.** And many of their employers have simply refused or been slow to provide personal protection equipment and to enact new safety procedures on the job.***

So, workers have had to take things into their own hands—not just individually (for example, by staying home), but collectively—by using one of the few tools at their disposal: the strike.

By my count, there have been more than a dozen work stoppages across the country in the past two weeks. They include the following:

Amazon workers on Staten Island (and the worker who organized the strike was subsequently fired)

Instacart employees

Whole Foods “sick-out”

Bath Iron Works shipbuilders

Fiat Chrysler plant in Michigan

Birmingham, Alabama bus drivers

Bus drivers in Detroit

Sanitation workers in Pittsburgh

Kroger warehouse workers in Memphis

•Workers at a Perdue processing plant in Kathleen, Georgia

•Cooks and cashiers at a McDonald’s restaurant in San José

•Fast-food workers at McDonald’s restaurants in St. Louis, Tampa, and Memphis

•Workers at a McDonald’s restaurant in Los Angeles

Other workers (for example, at the GE Appliances plant in Louisville, Kentucky) have engaged in protests against the reopening of factories.

Even in the best of times, millions of American workers are injured, succumb to illness, or die on the job.**** This year, unless employers are forced to implement the appropriate safeguards and give workers a say in when and how they work, we can expect those numbers to rise.

Until then, American workers will face a no-win situation and be forced to take matters into their own collective hands.


*Starting with the 13 March news conference, when Trump first (finally) declared a national emergency. Fortunately, more and more networks are cutting their coverage of or simply refusing to air the daily White House briefings.

**The recently passed Families First Coronavirus Response Act does require certain employers (only those with fewer than 500 employees) to provide workers with paid sick leave or expanded family and medical leave for specified reasons related to COVID-19, and only until the end of 2020.

***For example, it took Walmart, the nation’s largest employer, until this past Tuesday to start implementing new health and safety procedures for workers due to coronavirus concerns.

****According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics (pdf), 2.8 million nonfatal workplace injuries and illnesses were reported by private industry employers in 2018; 5,250 fatal work injuries were recorded by the BLS.

  1. Robert Locke
    April 4, 2020 at 11:40 am

    n 1819 Saint-Simon launched the journal, l’Organisateur, on which he,Thierry and Comte all participated.

    The opening letter in l’Organisateur was a scathing indictment of the current holders of power – the clergy, wealthy owners of industry, aristocracy, government and civil service, whom Saint-Simon characterised as useless idlers.He went on to claim that if they were all to die it would not harm France at all, while if the leading scientists, artists and skilled workers – the real producers of wealth – were to die then the country would truly suffer.”

    who are the real producers of wealth and the idlers today?

  2. Ken Zimmerman
    April 11, 2020 at 4:45 pm

    The current crisis shows convincingly that the actual redundant “workers” in American manufacturing, sales, services, etc. are CEOs, CFOs, etc. and particularly investors in it for the return. In this crisis they can perform no useful and certainly no necessary services, build or repair any necessary machines or equipment, nor make any of these processes more efficient or effective. Worker cooperatives can perform all of these tasks and manage the companies as well. And NYSE, NASDAQ, etc. are just expensive casinos with uncomfortable floor shows. But currently money (its mythology) rules the world. And those named above control a very large share of the money.

    • Robert Locke
      April 12, 2020 at 8:37 am

      German call financial capitalism, casino capitalism. It grasped a hold on the us economy in the 1980s and celebrated its maldistribution of wealth every since Want to get back to this hormal?

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.